2011-12 Yale Varsity Sport Captains
| Sport | Captain | |
| Baseball | Ryan Brenner '12 | |
| M-Basketball | Reggie Willhite '12 | |
| W-Basketball | Michelle Cashen '12 | |
| Heavyweight Crew | Thomas Dethlefs '12 | |
| Lightweight Crew | David Walker '12 | |
| W-Crew | Kathleen O'Keefe '12 | |
| M-Cross Country | Nathan Richards '12 | |
| W-Cross Country | Anne Lovelace '12 | |
| M-Fencing | Shiv Kachru '12 | |
| W-Fencing | Robyn Shaffer '13 | |
| Field Hockey | Erin Carter '12 | |
| Football | Jordan Haynes '12 | |
| M-Golf | Jeffrey Hatten '12 | |
| W-Golf | Lily Boettcher '12 | |
| Gymnastics | Mia Yabut '12 | |
| M-Ice Hockey | Brian O'Neill '12 | |
| W-Ice Hockey | Aleca Hughes '12 | |
| M-Lacrosse | Michael Pratt '12 | |
| W-Lacrosse | Caroline Crow '12 | |
| Co-Ed Sailing | Joseph Morris '12 | |
| W-Sailing | Margot Benedict '12 | |
| M-Soccer | Chris Dennen '12 | |
| W-Soccer | Miyuki Hino '12 | |
| Softball | Christy Nelson '13 | |
| M-Squash | Ryan Dowd '12 | |
| W-Squash | Rhetta Nadas '12 | |
| M-Swimming and Diving | Christopher Luu '12 | |
| W-Swimming and Diving | Rachel Rosenberg '12 | |
| M-Tennis | Erik Blumenkranz '12 | |
| W-Tennis | Steph Kent '12 | |
| M-Track and Field | Matthew Bieszard '12 | |
| W-Track and Field | Gabriella Kelly '12 | |
| Volleyball | Taylor Cramm '12 |