| 1977 | Anne F. Keating | Basketball, Field Hockey, Lacrosse | |
| 1978 | Barbara A. Liebowitz | Basketball | |
| 1979 | Mary C. Pew | Crew | |
| 1980 | Susanna E. Krentz | Volleyball, Basketball | |
| 1981 | Tracy Ball | Squash, Lacrosse | |
| 1982 | Patricia A. Melton | Track | |
| 1983 | Sindee L. Simon | Swimming | |
| 1984 | Nicole W. Piasecki | Field Hockey, Lacrosse | |
| 1985 | Andrea P. Metkus | Fencing | |
| 1986 | Melissa Jane Buchan | Track | |
| 1987 | Louisa Jennifer Gerritz | Track | |
| 1988 | Kelly Eve Groteke | Cross Country | |
| 1989 | Sarah P. Smith | Cross Country, Track | |
| 1990 | Tonya N. Lawrence | Basketball | |
| 1991 | Kristine A. Campbell | Fencing | |
| 1992 | Berkeley S. Belknap | Squash | |
| 1993 | Anne Louise Lehman | Field Hockey | |
| 1994 | Tasha Katherine Taylor | Gymnastics | |
| 1995 | Mary M. Kalich | Basketball | |
| 1996 | Kelianne Bartlett | Field Hockey, Softball | |
| 1997 | Amanda Rachel Taft | Softball | |
| 1998 | Laurie Clay Belliveau | Ice Hockey | |
| 1999 | Rosanna Lisa Wustrack | Volleyball | |
| 2000 | Heather R. Bentley | Lacrosse | |
| 2001 | Meredith Anne Bryarly | Swimming & Diving | |
| 2002 | Sarah Seung-Seo | Golf | |
| 2003 | Laura Carey O'Neill | Cross Country, Track & Field | |
| Kate Marie O'Neill | Cross Country, Track & Field | ||
| 2004 | Elizabeth Miles Whitman | Lacrosse | |
| 2005 | Sarah Driscoll | Field Hockey, Lacrosse | |
| 2006 | Michelle Quibell | Squash | |
| Joslyn Woodard | Track & Field | ||
| 2007 | Rachel Jeffers | Crew | |
| 2008 | Lauren Taylor | Lacrosse | |
| 2009 | Christina Person | Crew | |
| 2010 | Susan Kim | Swimming & Diving | |
| 2011 | Kate Grace | Cross Country, Track & Field | |
| 2012 | Taylor Cramm | Volleyball | Story |
| 2013 | Elizabeth Epstein | Tennis | Story |
| 2014 | Kendall Polan | Volleyball | Story |
| 2015 | Mollie Rogers | Volleyball | Story |
| 2016 | Eva Fabian | Swimming & Diving | Story |
| 2017 | Katherine Miller | Fencing | Story |
| Frances Schmiede | Cross Country, Track & Field | Story | |
| 2018 | Jen Berkowitz | Basketball | Story |