|High School:||Benet Academy|
Canulli was a three-time all-conference selection and three-time team most valuable player at Benet Academy. She was chosen to play in the Chicago Tribune's Super 60 Classic and the Chicago Bandits' High School All Star Game. In her four years, she had 172 hits, 27 doubles, nine home runs and 103 RBI. As a senior, she batted .345 with eight doubles and 31 RBI, and in her junior year, she led the team in seven offensive categories. Benet Academy was the regional champion in her senior and freshman seasons and captured the sectional crown in her sophomore and junior years. Canulli also played for the Stone City Marlins club team, which won the 2005 AFA National Tournament.